An Ecumenical Ministry in the Parish of St Patrick's Catholic Church In San Diego USA

Established in 1921 & Served by Augustinians

米国サンディエゴの聖パトリックカトリック教会教区におけるエキュメニカル宣教

1921年創立、アウグスティノ会が運営

Jesus was political and so are we ~ how christians vote matters

Our Mission: to see the baptized who live in SoNoGo worship in SoNoGo

Wednesday, November 18, 2026

The Spirit of Illumina, Part I

 

The whole of an authentic Christian life – indeed, of any upright and questing life on this earth – consists in a sort of wrestling match with the sheer, impossible enormity of God’s goodness. Confidence in this goodness is commensurate with perfection; the greatest saints were saints on this basis precisely. However much it might lie beyond the realm of empirical proof, faith in dominant authority is easy; the world makes us feel our subjugation a hundred ways in the course of a day. Projection follows quite naturally. But belief in mind-blowingly radical goodness?—such is another matter altogether. Eve was lured, not so much by the promise to be like a god, but by the scandal of a God who would hoard divinity. With that doubt sown, all was lost – after all, who wouldn’t cling to his rightful prerogative to absolute primacy? But God, in fact, does not; participation in his very life was the plan all along.

Like Socrates himself, our extraordinary philosophical mentor, Dr. Roger Duncan of blessed memory, understood that wisdom begins with wonder. He inculcated his students – and, rather famously, anyone anywhere who would hold still and listen – with his own sense of “the wonder of the real.” To truly see with wisdom, to see as God sees, is to see in all things that ineluctable goodness coextensive with their being.

“God looked at everything he had made, and found it very good”: Yes, this is a declaratory statement indicating the value of the contingent order, but to see only that (as if that weren’t in itself enough!) is too little. The text is also revelatory, disclosing God as the one who, of his nature, delights to affirm. In like wise: “God created mankind in his image; in the image of God he created them; male and female he created them.” In these lines we have, reigning before any derivative application, a revelation of who God is: namely, Relationship itself – to be imaged by no less than the composite: equality in diversity; fraternal cooperation; chaste eros and burning agape; love both paternal and maternal; orientation toward the “ever-greater” of the future.

But long prior to even this, we encounter first the fiat lux: “Let there be light!” Light is the prerequisite of the cosmos. Its uncreated mode bears within itself the splendor and telos of all things. Created light is itself presupposed by will, by voice… by Word. “In the beginning, when God created the heavens and the earth – and the earth was without form or shape, with darkness over the abyss and a mighty wind sweeping over the waters.” These streams and waters and loving energies, this profound and apophatic contemplation among the Persons, stirred as the lifeblood of the universe, before God in his priesthood spoke over it.

Pope Francis preached to the Pontifical Academy of Sciences: “When we read about Creation in Genesis, we run the risk of imagining God was a magician, with a magic wand able to do everything. But that is not so.”

What could Pope Francis have meant by this? And what exactly is magic anyway? We must imagine it as the arbitrary exercise of raw power, blind and callously indifferent to law, good or autonomy outside of its own sovereign subjectivity. The Christian God is not a god of magic. In fact, nothing could be further from the truth! Lest we confound divine omnipotence with earthly power, we must realize that the Almighty cannot deny himself. The Creator, the essence of Whom is to be, does not, in creating, violate the very being he so beneficently imparts.

The Big Bang cosmology, so-called, is a rightful point of pride in the Catholic intellectual heritage. It traces to the genius theoretical work of Monsignor Georges Lemaître, with which Pope Pius XII was utterly and enthusiastically taken. But Lemaître – priest, professor, mathematician and astrophysicist – never wrote or spoke of a “Big Bang”; those were the words of Sir Fred Hoyle, a scoffer who rejected the theory until his death in our own century. Neither science nor metaphysics hold for an angry paroxysm to jumpstart the universe. For Thomas Aquinas – professor, philosopher, theologian, and saint – the universe streams forth from the economic Trinity; creation is ever conceived and held in love.

What if time’s inaugural gesture was all gentleness, meant to gracefully and autonomously unfold into the embrace of the future and thus to evolve into the complexity of all things? “God said: Let there be light, and there was light. God saw that the light was good.” Bonum diffusivum sui. The good does not subjugate nor reign by destruction; it diffuses its very self in loving communion. What if the Service of Light at the Easter Vigil were the liturgical analogue of the mystical inner content of creation’s first moments? What if that one flame were to stretch itself, incorporating all within its flickering corona, unfurling its wings as it were, as a bird offers shelter and protection to its fledgling young? From the one primordial atom/Easter fire, the smallest, the very smallest flame, would arise against the darkness – and burn on today, undivided, in our presence lamps. That first light of the Fiat Lux was visibility and warmth, but also intelligibility and life, beauty and suffering and joy. Archetype, was it not Name and music?

Our attempt to set these foundational insights as art is Illumina: Awakening to the Wonder of Creation, a new largescale work for choirs, the Hazel Wright Organ, handbells, spatial sound, lights and projections highlighting the extraordinary architecture and acoustical properties of Christ Cathedral in the Diocese of Orange in California.

The music emerges from the lowest note of the cathedral organ — the 32-foot low C, vibrating at 16.35 Hz, just below the normal threshold of human hearing. This range is infrasonic – you rarely hear such a pitch with your ears. Rather, your body physically feels it as a tactile vibration or pressure in the chest and skin. From this fundamental tone unfolds the overtone series; in it, we “co-discern” – we are made to feel – the divine assessment of goodness, running ahead of our ordinary judgement, with all its prejudice and limitation. Our hearts must burn before our eyes are opened; music awakens the heart before the intellect grasps it, just as the visual world offers perception long before recognition arrives. Can an audience be gradually awakened until, in the final moments, they recognize what has been present all along?

Resonance is a central theme of the work. While the overtone series serves as the musical starting point, resonance is taken as ultimately much larger than a musical phenomenon – almost as one of the fundamental principles through which reality itself is organized. Patterns obtaining in the sonic domain mimic the core metaphysical concept of “analogy,” thus standing as a potent metaphor for relationship, participation and communion.

Birdsong, too, plays into the music. Passerine vocalization is not merely beautiful sound, but exists within systems governed by relationship, timing, adaptation, repetition, variation… and resonance. Migration, flocking behavior, ecological networks, biological growth reveal the complex relationships woven into the natural world as well. What science refers to as pattern, music deems harmony. To theology alone, however, is reserved the privilege of naming such as Logos.

As Pope Francis wrote, “In this universe, shaped by open and intercommunicating systems, we can discern countless forms of relationship and participation. This leads us to think of the whole as open to God’s transcendence, within which it develops. Faith allows us to interpret the meaning and the mysterious beauty of what is unfolding.” Creation is an outpouring of Trinitarian love.

This brings us back to goodness, and to light. The perennial tradition links goodness to the notion of desirability. This Thomistic definition is unimpeachable – things are good to that degree we would give to them the assent of our “yes.” Yet as theology develops, it has seemed to us to be offering something more. Through this project, and our preparatory study, we have come to suspect that goodness may reside, on a deeper level still, with the capacity within being to promote the good of the other, in quasi-indifference to subjective interest. Exploring this further falls beyond the scope of this essay, but we note here that the music has pushed us, quite unexpectedly, into new and exciting territory, even philosophically.

In developing Illumina, we have at length pondered together the mystery of light. Much of what we have seen is best expressed by Gabriel Marcel:

The special property of light is that it illuminates, it illuminates for others. This goes beyond the distinction between “for me” and “for others.” We might even say that this distinction does not exist for the light. If the joy of light is to be light, then it can only wish to be always more so. Light knows itself, then, as illuminating; and this knowledge is not like a sense of weakening and wasting itself, but on the contrary – it helps to increase its power. Like fire, generosity nurtures itself.

The radical goodness of God is manifest in his kenotic service to a rebellious creation, one not yet configured to the demands of limitless goodness. A suffering creation groans in its travail as it awaits its redemption – but that it groans implies that it can, so too, sing. Penultimate to its destiny of exultant praise, we have chosen the Lamentations of Jeremiah to represent its profound and tragic suffering. Jeremiah’s is a sacerdotal voice, made perfect in the crucible of abandonment, crying out against the myriad establishment prophets and their cheap and easy pacification of a people preferring their own ease over justice, esteeming political favor and mass popularity over adherence to truth. The Lamentations, intoned simultaneously in various tempi, constitute a startling glossolalia, a charismatic portrait of the interior life of pain and longing present within each member of the created order.

The goodness of God is not one which would forestall this pain and longing. Nay, more: the goodness of God identifies with it, stoops down to it in abasement and in tenderness. St. Peter Julian Eymard goes so far as to suggest that God willed specifically a saved cosmos – perhaps even in contradistinction to a pristine one – because one loves what he has personally saved even more than he could have otherwise. Ours is a faith which, in our most solemn liturgical moment, celebrates the happy fault, the “most necessary sin of Adam.” After the Lamentations of Tenebrae, the Paschal candle shining in the darkness. Like Jacob and the angel, we must wrestle with how expansive is the light of Christ.

No comments: