A small opinion essay ran in a corner of today’s Washington Post. It was easy to miss, but people of faith, and above all those of us who have worn the collar, should not miss it. Sergei Chapnin is the director of communications at Fordham’s Orthodox Christian Studies Center and was once executive editor of the Moscow Patriarchate’s official journal. He knows the Russian Orthodox Church from the inside. What he describes is a church that has made itself a mirror of the Kremlin.
The story at its center is simple and damning. Several months after Russia invaded Ukraine, a Moscow priest named Ioann Koval was celebrating the Divine Liturgy. He came to the prayer Patriarch Kirill had ordered read at every service, the one asking God to “grant us victory.” Father Koval prayed “grant us peace” instead.
An altar server reported him. A bishop barred him from the altar. By May 2023 a church court had stripped him of his priesthood. He lost it for changing one word, and the word was peace.
The altar boy
In May 2022, Pope Francis told Corriere della Sera about a forty-minute video call with Kirill. The Patriarch spent the first twenty minutes reading justifications for the war from a card. Francis said he told him, “Brother, we are not clerics of state, we cannot use the language of politics but that of Jesus.” Then came the line that made headlines: “The Patriarch cannot transform himself into Putin’s altar boy.”
That warning now looks prescient. Kirill did not heed it. He went further than any altar boy would. In September 2022, days after Putin announced mobilization, he preached that a soldier who dies doing his duty offers a sacrifice that washes away all his sins. No Orthodox tradition ever taught this. St. Basil the Great kept soldiers who had killed in battle from Communion for three years. In the tenth century the Byzantine emperor Nikephoros Phokas asked the Church to honor his fallen soldiers as martyrs, and the patriarch and synod of Constantinople refused. A thousand years later, the Patriarch of Moscow has given Caesar what Constantinople would not.
Now Kirill has a book, published this July, that justifies a war of conquest against a people he himself calls brothers. Its most brazen passage claims that the soldier who rises to defend the Fatherland is the one keeping the commandment “Thou shalt not kill.” A commandment you keep by doing its opposite is no longer a commandment. It is propaganda in liturgical vestments. And by his own logic, the soldier keeping the commandment is the one defending Kharkiv, not the one who crossed the border in February 2022.
This is not theology. It is the vocation of a false prophet. “Beware of false prophets, who come to you in sheep’s clothing, but underneath are ravenous wolves” (Matthew 7:15). It is shameful. Defrocking a priest for praying for peace is worse than shameful. It is sinful. It punishes a man for keeping the Beatitudes: “Blessed are the peacemakers, for they will be called children of God” (Matthew 5:9).
Father Koval was not alone. Father Alexei Uminsky, one of Moscow’s most beloved pastors, refused to read the prayer for victory and was defrocked in January 2024. Ecumenical Patriarch Bartholomew, who condemned the invasion on its first day, received both men. They serve in his parishes today. If Russian Orthodoxy has a future, Chapnin writes, it looks like them. I agree.
Not bound to any political system
Our own tradition is clear on this. Gaudium et Spes teaches that the Church is not identified with any political community and is not bound to any political system. She is “a sign and a safeguard of the transcendent character of the human person” (GS 76). When the Church becomes the chaplaincy of the state, she loses that freedom. Once she loses it, she has nothing left to say.
Pope Francis took the just war tradition seriously enough to ask whether modern warfare can still meet its criteria. His answer in Fratelli Tutti was a cry: “Never again war!” (FT 258). Kirill went the other way. He drafted that tradition into the service of an aggressor.
We have seen this before. In 1934 the “German Christians” draped the swastika over the altar and welcomed a Reich Bishop. Dietrich Bonhoeffer and the Confessing Church answered with the Barmen Declaration. It rejected the false teaching that the Church must recognize other lords besides Jesus Christ. Bonhoeffer paid for that witness with his life. In 1980 St. Óscar Romero stood in his cathedral pulpit and ordered soldiers, in the name of God, to stop the repression. He was shot at the altar the next evening. Those are the pastors the Church canonizes. History does not canonize the court chaplains.
The sobering lesson closer to home
It would be easy, and disingenuous, to read Chapnin’s essay as a story about Russia alone. It is not. Chapnin says as much: Moscow markets itself as the defender of “traditional values,” and many Western Christians hear an ally in that phrase.
Religious leaders in our own country are being courted too. The courtship comes from a government that has drifted from its democratic moorings in pursuit of power and mammon, and then asks to be baptized. Last month I wrote about the bishops who laid hands in prayer on the President in the Oval Office. Praying for those in authority is our duty. Lending the visible authority of the episcopacy to a political project is something else. That is the first step on the road Kirill has walked to its end.
The pattern is always the same. First comes access, then flattery, then a photograph. Then the shepherd hesitates to say the inconvenient word, whether it is peace, the stranger, or the poor, because it might cost him his seat at the table. Finally the shepherd speaks the language of the palace instead of the language of Jesus. Kirill did not begin as Putin’s altar boy. He became one, one accommodation at a time.
“You cannot serve God and mammon” (Matthew 6:24). Nor can a bishop serve both the Gospel and Caesar’s agenda. When the Sanhedrin ordered the apostles to be silent, Peter answered: “We must obey God rather than men” (Acts 5:29). That is the oath that matters. Father Koval kept it when he changed one word, and he paid the price.
So who do we serve? Kirill has given his answer. Every bishop, every priest, and every baptized Christian in our own land must give theirs. Let us give ours plainly, without a scintilla of ambiguity, and in the word his church could not forgive: peace. Peace for Ukraine. Peace in the names of Ioann Koval and Alexei Uminsky. And peace as our refusal to let the altar ever again become Caesar’s footstool.
Monsignor Arthur Holquin, S.T.L.

No comments:
Post a Comment