An Ecumenical Ministry in the Parish of St Patrick's Catholic Church In San Diego USA

Established in 1921 & Served by Augustinians

米国サンディエゴの聖パトリックカトリック教会教区におけるエキュメニカル宣教

1921年創立、アウグスティノ会が運営

Jesus was political and so are we ~ how christians vote matters

Our Mission: to see the baptized who live in SoNoGo worship in SoNoGo

Tuesday, October 27, 2026

The Diaconate and Women: Why It Matters Today

 

In 2026, that is, today, talking about the diaconate and about a role for women — the female diaconate — is not revolutionary. It is not a topic reserved for a handful of experts. On the contrary, it is an issue that should concern all of us.

Of course, the final decision belongs to the Pope. Perhaps the Synod of Bishops on synodality, with its ecclesial assembly in 2028, will offer some indications. But it is important that all the faithful, the People of God, be informed about the importance of knowing and studying the diaconate.

This is why two books are important, one published in the United States and one in Italy. In the United States, the book The Vatican and Women Deacons was written by Phyllis Zagano. In Italy, the book Il diaconato tra storia, esperienze e prospettive: Un ruolo per le donne is mine, published by Città Nuova, a Catholic publishing house associated with the Focolare Movement.

So, what is the importance of this issue?

Talking about the diaconate takes us back to the history of the Church, beginning with the Acts of the Apostles and the Letters of Paul of Tarsus. We are in the fifties of the first century, right at the beginning of the Christian adventure that changed the world.

The Christian community was growing, and the Apostles realized that they needed some form of organizational structure. They established the ministry of the Seven, in order to assist people in need (Acts 6:1–6). This is where the diaconate begins. From its very origins, Christianity was characterized by charity, care, mercy, and closeness to those in need.

At the end of the Letter to the Romans (Rom 16:1), Paul of Tarsus sends his greetings to Phoebe, a “deaconess” in Cenchreae, the port of Corinth in Greece. The translation is important because the word “deaconess” appears in the 1974 Italian Bible translation of the Italian Bishops’ Conference, while in the 2008 translation it becomes “who serves the Church of Cenchreae.”

The 2003 document of the International Theological Commission, entirely devoted to studying the historical and theological development of the diaconate, clearly states that a female diaconate existed in the Church during the first centuries:

“The present historical overview shows that a ministry of deaconesses did indeed exist, and that this developed unevenly in the different parts of the Church. It seems clear that this ministry was not perceived as simply the feminine equivalent of the masculine diaconate. At the very least it was an ecclesial function, exercised by women, sometimes mentioned together with that of sub-deacon in the lists of Church ministries.”

This statement appears at the end of the second chapter.

Later, over the centuries, the diaconate became one of the stages leading to the priesthood, and it was only after the Second Vatican Council that the diaconate was rediscovered as a specific ministry, also open to laymen, whether married or celibate, who are ordained to assist priests.

But today’s diaconate is very different from the diaconate of the Christian communities of the first centuries. Since the Second Vatican Council, the Church has addressed the diaconate on several occasions. Phyllis Zagano’s book provides a good account of the work carried out by various study commissions. My book also discusses these commissions, pointing out that they reached different conclusions. Some were in favor of restoring a female diaconate, while others were opposed.

The most recent commission, established by Pope Francis and coordinated by Cardinal Giuseppe Petrocchi, concluded in December 2025 that further study of the diaconate in the first centuries is still necessary because we do not know enough about it.

This is not entirely true. As the International Theological Commission shows, we actually know a great deal, and its 2003 document is very long, precise, and detailed in reconstructing the entire history of the diaconate. I discuss and explain this in my book. So what is the fundamental issue at the heart of the whole question? Certainly, the role of women.

Today, we cannot imagine excluding women simply by repeating that Jesus chose only male disciples to be with him. In the Gospels, Jesus’ attitude toward the women he encounters is not the attitude one would expect from a first-century Jew. And it is especially different from the attitude of the Pharisees, who wanted to stone an adulterous woman (Jn 8:1–11).

So the cultural argument is certainly weak.

Throughout the history of the Church, many theologians held discriminatory views toward women. In my book, for example, I discuss Thomas Aquinas and others. But that was the Middle Ages, and perhaps things could not have been otherwise. After all, there were the Crusades, wars of religion, and schisms, and heretics were burned at the stake. Let us hope that these are only stories from the past, never to be repeated.

Pope Francis opened a new path with the motu proprio Spiritus Domini of January 11, 2021, which opened the ministries of lector and acolyte to women. We already had female altar servers. These are signs that something can be done. At the very least, we can talk about it.

Church historians, biblical scholars, and the most up-to-date and open-minded theologians know very well that the structures of today’s Church — from the priesthood to the papacy — are not simply based on the Gospel. Rather, they developed gradually over the centuries as responses to organizational needs. Today’s priesthood, as well as the organization of parishes, seminaries, and formation, has its roots in the Council of Trent, five hundred years ago. The liturgy, too, about which there is so much discussion — Mass in Latin or not, the old rite or the new rite — also comes from the Council of Trent and, later, from the reform of the Second Vatican Council.

It is not found in the Gospel. We are dealing with a complex and fascinating subject.

Certainly, the responsibility and duty to provide guidance belongs to the Pope. And whatever decision is made, we will respect it. But we are at a stage where we can discuss, talk, and explore the issue in greater depth — through books, conferences, dialogue, and contributions to the mass media. This too is a task of the People of God.


Image: Third-century fresco of a woman in the orans liturgical posture in the Cubiculum of the Velatio, Catacomb of Priscilla, Rome, from Joseph Wilpert, Die Malereien der Katakomben Roms (1903), Plate 80 (Public Domain, via Wikimedia Commons).

No comments: